From Room to Roadmap: Translating Track II Outcomes into Policy Change
Standfirst:
Track II only matters if outcomes travel. This piece lays out mechanisms to convert backchannel ideas into policy steps, with realistic metrics and safeguards.
The uptake chain
-
Productize insights
Draft a two-page non-paper: the problem, 3–5 actionable steps, minimal legal/operational notes, and a “first 30/60/90 days” ladder. -
Secure relays
Identify trusted “policy carriers” (senior advisors, special envoys, committee chairs) who can brief principals under time pressure. -
Pilot before policy
Propose micro-pilots (e.g., a single crossing, a 72-hour de-confliction window, a forensic identification protocol) to reduce political risk and generate proof-points. -
Legal/operational vetting
Pre-clear options against IHL/IHRL, sanctions regimes, and domestic law to avoid Track I rejection on process grounds. -
Feedback loop
Establish a backchannel to receive Track I reactions, adjust language, and iterate quickly.
M&E: showing results without overselling
-
Activity metrics: sessions held, attendance continuity, gender/sector balance.
-
Output metrics: non-papers delivered; pilots agreed; language adopted in communiqués.
-
Outcome indicators (contribution, not attribution): humanitarian access hours, detainee release processes trialed, hotline functionality uptime.
-
Learning: what failed and why; assumptions updated.
Risk management
-
Do no harm: identify red-lines (e.g., proposals that could endanger communities if leaked).
-
Consent & confidentiality: protect participants and sources.
-
Expectation management: be explicit that Track II generates options, not promises.
Editor’s note (opinion): The fastest way to earn Track I trust is to bring options that are legally sound, logistically credible, and politically “lightweight” enough to test tomorrow morning.
References
-
USIP: Guide to mediation & policy linkage;
-
OECD-DAC adaptive programming notes;
-
Berghof Handbook M&E in peace processes;
-
Saunders’ “sustained dialogue” model for iterative uptake.

