Ethical OSINT for Policymakers: From Collection to Court-Proof Briefs
Standfirst:
Open-source intelligence (OSINT) can illuminate fast-moving crises—if it is collected ethically, verified rigorously, and documented so it can stand up to scrutiny.
What to collect (and why)
-
Imagery & video: Satellite, commercial drone, user-generated content (UGC).
-
Telemetry: AIS for vessels, ADS-B for aircraft.
-
Documents & datasets: Official releases, UN/OCHA updates, World Bank/IMF macro data.
-
Local media & NGO reporting: For ground truth and timelines.
Verification workflow (four steps)
-
Provenance: Source mapping; original upload where possible; archive first.
-
Geolocation: Terrain, landmarks, shadows; cross-check with satellite basemaps.
-
Chronolocation: Sun-angle, weather records, metadata, platform timestamps.
-
Corroboration: Triangulate with independent sources (official reports, humanitarian datasets).
Chain of custody & documentation
-
Use immutable hashes; log every handling step; store originals read-only.
-
Maintain method notes and a limitations section (e.g., compression artifacts).
-
Clearly separate facts, inferences, and opinions in the final brief.
Ethics & legal safeguards
-
Do-no-harm: blur identities when disclosure could endanger individuals; follow data minimization and necessity/proportionality principles.
-
Respect platform terms and copyright; cite sources; obtain consent where feasible.
-
Align with international humanitarian law when documenting alleged violations; avoid interfering with ongoing operations.
Products decision-makers actually use
-
Incident cards (1 page each): what/where/when/so-what; geolocation image; confidence level.
-
Situation map (updated daily): overlays with humanitarian corridors and no-strike areas (if relevant).
-
Policy annex: risk implications, options, and collection gaps that matter for decisions.
Editor’s note (opinion): If it isn’t reproducible, it isn’t intelligence—it’s just a claim. Your documentation is the product.
References
UN OCHA/HDX guidance on humanitarian data; ICRC professional standards for protection work (on data protection & do-no-harm); OECD privacy/AI principles; World Bank data catalog standards; UK GOVSCE/UK OSINT professional guidance (open publications); EU Fundamental Rights Agency guidance on OSINT & privacy (public materials).

